Melina vs. Ashley

Lumberjill Match for the Women's Championship

129 Oracles have spoken

Melina
Melina
41.09%
(53 predictions - 41.09%)
Ashley Massaro
Ashley Massaro
56.59%
(73 predictions - 56.59%)
Draw
(3 Predictions - 2.33%)
Result:Melina wins



Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:I agree with tocc on this 2 ashely was put on SD after her raw injury she will come to raw
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:People love Ashley now that they have seen her nekkid.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:I've gotta go with Ashley. True, Wrestlemania hasn't been nice to their covergirls in the past (Christy at WM 21, Candice at WM 22), but I have a feeling the reason why Mickie dropped the title was to have Ashley win it here.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:she is on top of the world and with all her luck she will win
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:im gonna stick with melina...ashley is on smackdown and i dont see her as being a womens champion just yet...she has had all the publicity with playboy and i think honestly that melina is a better wrestler and champion right now
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Dont Care
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:I hate melina because she is a nasty woman. I hope she gets hurt.
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Awful just awful!! How can wwe justify putting 2 horrible female wrestlers on a WM card is beyond me. All you people looking forward to this match are a disgrace,think of the wrestlers not on the card but should be in place of this shit. Diva matches on TV shows only please, wwe. They swerved us last year when we thought Trish was going to retain against Mickie J,so Melina will def retain here for me.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:Ashley will win and come to Raw because Melina has been getting some heat backstage and I was surprised to see Melina win the Women's Championship.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:She'll move to Raw.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:She doesn't deserve it though. I'm guessing she moves to Raw, but even if she doesn't, she can defend the title against Jillian Hall at least until the next interbrand PPV. And since all PPVs will now be interbrand, that won't be very long. Also, considering that Melina supposedly is actually in danger of losing her job if she doesn't put on a good match here (supposedly it's partly her attitude, and partly because she doesn't protect her opponents physically very well), I can't see them keeping the title on her. Say, remember the days when if one of the WWE's "Divas" was going to be in Playboy, it only happened _after_ they became popular with the crowd first so there was no need to try and ram her down everyone's throats?
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:I agree with the tocc and jenny
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:She's the third best womens wrestler in the company. Ashley's work isn't good enough for her to go over Melina
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Ashley is a piece of trash. She will not beat the best women's champion of all time.
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Melina.... so the story goes on. She is gonna cheat for the champion, then on Raw tensions are gonna rise for drama.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:Just throwing my pick no big deal.
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:i would have to go with melina on this one. because even though she's a heel, i don't think the womens championship will be going to smackdown.
Prediction:Ashley Massaro
Prophecy:I pick Ashley with a double turn, both divas and Mickie are in tweener status at the moment, Melina and Nitro's relationship is fading, I see Ashley winning the gold with a double-turn, the title goes to SMACKDOWN!, in turn, the CW Title goes to ECW, As Ashley turned heel is beating Melina, turned face, Mickie James comes in and looks like is gonna help Melina, but Mickie turns heel and joins Ashley, Ashley announces that her and mickie are the Co-Holders of the women's title, and all 3 divas go to SMACKDOWN! along with the whole division and the title, and they lose the Cruiserweights to ECW, and hopefully Maria will turn heel and join Mickie and Ashley!
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Always with these woman championship matches its always the heel to win... especially at WM
Prediction:Melina
Prophecy:Christy Hemme didn't beat Trish Stratus. Why should Ashley beat Melina? Why is Ashley in Wrestlemania? This is a joke, like most of this card.